
It seems like a small freedom: working from Spain or Portugal for a week, when the laptop works just as well at home. For many employees, working remotely from abroad has long ceased to be the exception. But what does the law say about this? And is an employer actually allowed to prohibit it? Recent summary proceedings involving Statistics Netherlands (CBS) bring this question into sharp focus.
An employee of Statistics Netherlands (CBS) wanted to work from abroad on a structural basis. The employer refused to give permission. The employee went to court and, in summary proceedings, claimed the right to work from abroad. The court rejected the claim: the employer had good reasons for refusing permission, and those reasons were allowed to outweigh the employee’s personal interest.
Many employees assume that if working from home is permitted, working from abroad is automatically included. That is not the case. Working from another country raises a whole range of legal questions in which the employer has a direct interest: which employment law applies, where is the employee insured for social security purposes, what are the tax consequences, and are there permit requirements in the country of work? These questions are not merely administrative – they affect the employer’s liability.
Employers are therefore well advised to adopt a clear policy on international remote work. Without explicit permission, employees are not entitled to work from abroad, even if they have permission for hybrid working in the Netherlands.
Under Article 7:660 of the Dutch Civil Code, the employer has the right to give instructions: it can issue directions on how the work is to be performed, including the place of work. This right is not unlimited – it may not conflict with the duty to act as a good employer – but it does provide a solid legal basis for setting limits on where the work is carried out. The ruling in the CBS case confirms that courts are reluctant to set aside this right to give instructions on the basis of an individual interest of the employee.
The outcome of these summary proceedings is a good moment to take a critical look at your own policy. Practical points to consider include: have you set out in employment contracts or staff handbooks where employees may carry out their work, have you considered the limits and conditions for occasional work from abroad, and are your HR and payroll departments set up to identify situations involving work abroad in good time?
A policy does not necessarily have to be rigid. Some employers opt for a pragmatic approach in which they do allow occasional work from abroad – for example, up to four weeks a year – provided the employee reports this in good time and the tax and social security risks remain manageable. This gives employees flexibility while the employer stays in control.
The CBS ruling shows that employees cannot force employers to agree to work from abroad. But it also shows that employers benefit from a clear, consistent policy – not only to prevent disputes, but also to keep a grip on the legal and tax risks that come with international remote work.
Do you have questions about drafting or amending a policy on working from home internationally, or would you like your employment contracts reviewed on this point? The employment law specialists at De Clercq Advocaten will be happy to help. For questions, please contact Caroline Mehlem, attorney at law in Employment & Employee Participation.
Would you like to receive a monthly overview of our latest legal updates and blog articles? Subscribe to our newsletter.